Thursday, January 26, 2012

Blast from the Past- History Hare 1/26/2012

MOURNING VISITING CARDS

by footnoteMaven

Often when researching, I am taken completely by surprise when a simple "nothing extraordinary" photograph or piece of ephemera, turns out to be anything but simple. When research starts it often takes on a life of its own and literally explodes.

So it was with a group of visiting cards I purchased. The group was of fifty plain, name only, no decoration, visiting cards, early 1900s. I purchased them because the lot description said there were two cards with black borders. I hoped these were mourning cards, but the seller did not know and was just getting rid of some paper ephemera he had purchased at an estate sale. I purchased them, hoping they'd be what I was looking for.

When the visiting cards arrived I gave them a cursory look, found the two cards with black trim, determined they were indeed mourning cards, and was surprised to find what appeared to be the cards of a mother and son. The real surprise came when the research began. First we'll explore the history of mourning visiting cards and then the history of the people represented by the cards themselves.

Visiting Cards

Visiting cards were the custom in the United States in the Victorian and Edwardian periods. Some say the origins of the card can be traced to ancient Egypt, others say the French wrote names and messages on the backs of playing cards and from there these evolved into a card which was engraved with a facsimile of the signature of the owner.

The etiquette of calling, or visiting, had some very firmly established rules of society. Visiting was viewed as a female occupation and was not done for pleasure, but as an obligation. Cards played a vital role in these visits.

As callers passed through on their way into the drawing room, cards were left on the tray in the hall. If no one were at home, the card would be left with a servant. At this point in the visiting card transactions there were numerous customs to follow, far too numerous for this article.

Visiting Cards - Mourning

People who were in mourning were to use black-edged visiting cards, letter paper and envelopes. In America we had no hard and fast rules regulating the depth of mourning border on a visiting card.

An extremely broad band was frowned upon as too ostentatious a sign of grief, even when a widow or a bereaved parent used it.

In the first year of widowhood, a border of one-third of an inch wide was a sufficient indication of the profoundest depths of grief. In the second year a border of a third of an inch wide was adopted and continued for six or eight months to a full year.

Every six months the border was diminished by a sixteenth of an inch until mourning was put off entirely. On the card of a widower, since a man's card was always smaller than a woman's, the black border was always narrower; it narrowed from time to time by about the same margins as on the card of a widow.

A gradual narrowing in the black border was not considered in good taste when the death was that of a parent, a child, a sister or a brother. The card for any of those relatives, from the beginning to the end of the period of mourning, bore a black edging from an eighth to a sixteenth of an inch in width. A border a sixteenth of an inch wide was sufficient for the whole period in mourning in case of the death of a grandparent, or of an uncle or an aunt.

Here are the two mourning visiting cards that I purchased.

Mrs. Burd Grubb
July 1913
Mr. Edward Burd Grubb, Jr.
July 1913

Notice that Mrs. Burd Grubb’s card is larger than that of her son, as was the convention. The black border on her card is larger than that of her son, as also was the convention. Though my research found that Edward Burd Grubb, Jr. did not use the Junior in his professional life, it was the convention to add the Junior to the mourning card where it was the Senior that had died.

Edward Burb Grubb, Sr.

Edward Burb Grubb was born in Burlington, New Jersey, on November 13, 1841, the son of Edward Burb Grubb, a prosperous iron manufacturer and miner, and his wife Euphemia Parker. Grubb was descended from a family of large landed estates, derived by patent from William Penn. He graduated with honors from Burlington College in 1860; served with distinction in the Civil War, rising through various grades to the rank of brigadier-general.


Grubb married Elizabeth Wadsworth Van Rensselaer October 6, 1868. They had one daughter, Euphemia Van Rensselaer Burd Grubb. Elizabeth died April 17, 1886.

Grubb was the republican candidate for governor in 1888, and the following year was appointed by President Harrison as the United States minister to Spain.

A widower when he went to Spain as U.S. minister in 1890, he met Violet Sopwith, an Englishwoman, and was married in London in 1891. Violet is the Mrs. Burd Grubb of the mourning visiting card.

General Grubb died July 7, 1913. He was one of the most prominent and honored citizens of New Jersey. The first monument to a Northern officer in Southern soil was erected in his honor at Salem Church near Fredericksburg, Virginia.

Mrs. Burd Grubb

Violet was the daughter of Thomas Sopwith of London, a Scottish mining engineer and his wife L.G. Messister. Her brother was the Sopwith of aviation fame and an ardent yachtsman. Violet was known as the Rose of Lismore, named for the Argyllshire residence of her father. She was a blue-eyed beauty considered one of the belles of London society.

Violet and General Grubb were married at St. Stephen's Church, South Kensington, London. One of the bridesmaids was Effie Grubb, the General's daughter from his first marriage. Over 1200 people attended. Most of the European diplomatic corps were there. Telegrams were received from President Benjamin Harrison, Vice President Levi P. Morton, and Mr. James G. Blaine, Secretary of State.

March 20, 1893, Edward Burd Grubb, Jr. was born to the couple.

Violet received the Royal Order of Maria Louisa from the Queen Regent of Spain. During World War I she was chairman of the British War Relief Committee in Philadelphia.

Unable to walk after an automobile accident in 1944, Violet was allowed out of bed only two hours a day. During that time she would help a disabled veteran of World War II sell papers at a news-stand. Violet died 4 July 1958, at the age of 92.

Edward Burd Grubb, Jr.

Edward Burd Grubb, Jr., was assistant Philadelphia sales manager of the U. S. Cast Iron Pipe & Foundry Co., 1912-1915; bond salesman Chandler & Co. and Elkins, Morris. Philadelphia, 1915-1920: Junior partner firm of MacQuoid & Coady 1920: Pres. N. Y. Alaska Gold Dredging Co.

Edward was also a stock broker and a President of the New York Stock Exchange.

June 3, 1916, when Edward married his first wife, Helen MacQuoid, it was the largest wedding ever held in New Jersey. 2700 invitations were sent. Among those in attendance were President and Mrs. Wilson and Secretary and Mrs. McAdoo.

Who would have thought, all this information from two mourning visiting cards.

Sources:


Banfield, Edwin. Visiting Cards and Cases. Trowbridge : England, 1989.


Holt, Emily. Encyclopaedia of Etiquette : What To Write, What To Do, What To Wear, What To Say: A Book of Manners For Everyday Use. New York : McClure, Phillips, 1903.

Who's Who in Finance, Banking, and Insurance
.
New York : Who's Who in Finance, Inc. (N.Y.), 1922.

2700 Invited to Wedding.
New York Times, Jun 4, 1916. Online Archives. http://www.proquest.com : 2009.

GI Newsstand Run By Envoy's Widow.
New York Times, Jun 18, 1949. Online Archives. http://www.proquest.com : 2009.
Minister Grubb Marries. New York Times, November 4, 1891. Online Archives. http://www.proquest.com : 2009.

Mrs. E. Burd Grubb, Widow of Ex-Envoy To Spain, a Union Army General, Dead.
New York Times, July 5, 1958. Online Archives. http://www.proquest.com : 2009.

Thursday, January 19, 2012

SOS and Graveyard Guru 1/19/2012


Grave markers Stolen from Woolwich Maine Cemetery   By Kim Sawtelle

In early January 2012, two significant, historical grave markers were reported missing from the Nequasset Cemetery in Woolwich, Maine.

The first marker, dating from Maine's colonial period, is dedicated to the memory of Deacon Samuel Ford. The thin, tablet-style marker, features a unique winged-head design with the inscription, "Know ye the Hour." Additional historical information about the marker is available through the Maine Memory Network online at http://www.mainememory.net/artifact/12469/.



The second missing marker belongs to the grave of Reverend Josiah Winship, who departed this life Sept. 28, 1824. This slate marker features an elegantly carved willow-and-urn motif, as can be seen in the attached image, photocopied from the January 2012 Maine Antique Digest.

Please share this information widely among your friends and associates, including antique dealers.

Any information regarding the missing stones should be directed to the Maine State Police, or the stones may be returned to the Nequasset Cemetery.





A Masonic Funeral Ritual
By Stephanie Lincecum


Back in 2010, I contributed an article to the Graveyard Rabbit Online Journal about the many symbols of Freemasonry.  I’d like to take that subject a bit further and point you to some great information regarding Masonic funerals.

I’ve seen many an obituary that tells of the deceased being buried with Masonic rites, and / or that the Masonic lodge of which they were a member was handling the funeral.  I was never before quite sure what that might entail, until I happened to research an epitaph.

The stone which bore the inscription was erected for Reverend Thomas Darley, and stands in Waverley Hall Cemetery at Harris County, Georgia.  Here’s the full inscription:

“This monument is erected by order of the most worshipfull Grand Lodge of Georgia, to the Memory of their former Grand Chaplain, Reverend Thomas Darley, who departed this life, 18th April A.L. 5832, A.D. 1832, in the 63rd year of his age: and who was a shining light to his Masonic Brethren, to imitate in his walk, as a man, Mason, and Christian.”


On the back of his monument is the following:

“Calm, the good man meets his fate,
Guards celestial around him wait!
See! he bursts these mortal chains,
And o'er death the victory gains.
”

These lines are connected to Masonic history. A Google search of the first line of the epitaph, "Calm the good man meets his fate," revealed a poem written by David Vinton (1774-1833). Mr. Vinton was a prominent member of the Masonic fraternity as a member of Mount Vernon Lodge No. 4 of Providence, Rhode Island. He compiled and published a hymnal entitled "The Masonic Minstrel" in 1816. The epitaph on Rev. Darley's stone is the final stanza in a dirge included in the book set to "Pleyel's Hymn." A dirge is a somber song expressing mourning or grief, such as would be appropriate for performance at a funeral.

That lead me to Funeral Service: Most Worshipful Grand Lodge of Ancient Freemasons. While the link takes you to information from an 1899 pamphlet distributed in South Carolina, the information appears to apply to all members of the fraternity. Though I cannot say for sure how often this funeral ritual was actually performed (or if it was used at the funeral for Rev. Darley), here are a few highlights:

"No Freemason can be interred with the formalities of the Order, unless it be at his own request, or by that of some of his family, communicated to the Master of the Lodge of which he died a member (foreigners and transient brethren excepted); nor unless he has received the Master's degree; and from this restriction there can be no exception. Fellow Crafts and Apprentices are not entitled to funeral obsequies; nor to attend the Masonic processions on such occasions.

When the Master of a Lodge receives notice of a Master Mason's death, and of his request to be interred as a Mason, he must satisfy himself of its propriety; and then, being informed of the time appointed for the funeral, the Master may invite as many Lodges as he may think proper, and the members of those Lodges may accompany their officers in form; but the whole ceremony must be under the direction of the Master of the Lodge to which the deceased belonged, and he and his officers must be duly honored and cheerfully obeyed on the solemn occasion.

The proper clothing for a Masonic funeral, is a black hat, black or dark clothes, white gloves and a plain white lambskin apron, with a band of crape around the left arm above the elbow, and a sprig of evergreen on the left breast. The Master's gavel, the Warden's columns, the Deacon's and Steward's rods, the Tiler's sword, the Bible, the Book of Constitutions, and the Marshal's baton, should be draped with black crape. The officers of the Lodge and past Masters and Grand Officers, may wear their official jewels.

The brethren being assembled at the Lodge room, or some other convenient place, the Master of the Lodge to which the deceased belonged opens the Lodge in the third degree. A procession is then formed to the house of the deceased and thence to the grave...

...When the procession arrives at the gate of the church-yard, the Lodge to which the deceased brother belonged, and the mourners and attendants on the corpse, halt, until the members of the other Lodges have formed a circle round the grave, when an opening is made to receive them. They then advance to the grave; where the clergyman and officers of the acting Lodge take their station at the head of the grave, and the mourners at the foot. The Marshal will remove the apron from the coffin to be handed in to the Master at the proper time; the coffin is then lowered into the grave and after the clergyman has concluded the religious services of the church, (unless the same have been previously concluded) the Masonic service begins...

...[After words are spoken according to ritual] They then form a chain, with the left arm over the right, and march three times around the grave, while they sing the... [Pleyel's] hymn..."

More words according to ritual are spoken, and the members return to the lodge and close with the usual benediction.

Another interesting note connecting to Rev. Darley: he would've been one to perform a service such as this for a Grand Officer, during the time he was Grand Chaplain.

Thursday, January 12, 2012

Digging for Answers 1/12/2011


Digging for Answers -- WHAT IS PERPETUAL CARE?
by Randy Seaver

Welcome to the Digging for Answers column on the Graveyard Rabbit Online Journal.


This column will depend on your submission of questions about cemeteries, gravestones, burial practices, and other topics that concern a Graveyard Rabbit (other than where his next carrot is coming from!). So please send some questions to the editor, who will pass them along and keep the columnist hopping.

Question:  What is perpetual care of graves in cemeteries?

Answer:  By definition, "perpetual care" means "means the care and maintenance and the reasonable administration of the cemetery grounds and buildings at the present time and in the future."
  Some cemeteries have sections designated for perpetual care while other sections are not so designated.  "Endowment care" is a synonymous term for "perpetual care" used in some states.

Perpetual care of graves in cemeteries is usually covered by the fees paid by the owners of the burial plots - a certain percentage of the fees go into an investment trust fund held by the cemetery and the perpetual care needs are funded by the interest accrued on the trust fund itself, and the cemetery should not touch the principal. 

In perpetual care cemetery sections, the cemetery is supposed to do the routine maintenance and landscaping around the gravesites, the grass mowing, the leave raking, the tree and bush trimming, road maintenance, water line and drain repair, etc.  using the interest income from the investment trust funds. 
Sometimes, the cemetery uses the principal investment for other reasons, or a sexton or other cemetery employee absconds with the funds.

Apparently, there is no federal law governing maintenance and care of cemeteries.  Title 26 of the Internal Revenue Service code has guidelines for cemeteries - paragraph
§ 1.642(i)-1 Certain distributions by cemetery perpetual care funds and paragraph § 1.642(i)-2 Definitions. It describes how states and other jurisdictions should operate perpetual care cemeteries and how contributions to them should be handled.

There are laws in every U.S. state that define how cemeteries should operate.  They vary from state to state.  For your specific state, I suggest that you use an online search engine to search for [cemetery law statename] and then search for "perpetual" or "endowment" on the site.

For instance, the Georgia law governing perpetual care [O.C.G.A. § 10-14-6, http://sos.georgia.gov/Securities/perpetual_care_cemetery.htm#Perpetual Care Trust Fund] says:

"Each perpetual care cemetery must establish and maintain an irrevocable trust fund. An initial deposit of $10,000.00 must be made before selling or contracting to sell any burial right. See O.C.G.A. § 10-14-6. The trust fund applies to sales or contracts for sale of lots, grave spaces, niches, mausoleums, columbaria, urns, or crypts in which perpetual care has been promised or contracted for or guaranteed. See O.C.G.A. § 10-14-6(b). The cemetery must make deposits to the trust fund that equal 15 percent of the sale price of the burial right or 7.5 percent of the total sales price of any mausoleums, niches, columbaria, urns, or crypts, provided that the minimum deposit for each burial right must be $55.75 effective July 1, 2006. The minimum deposit rate is adjusted every three years according to the consumer Price Index. See O.C.G.A. § 10-14-6(b). Deposits to the trust fund must be made no later than 30 days following the last day of the month in which payment is received, or, in the case of a free space, the month in which the space is given."

A search for California's laws about perpetual or endowment care resulted in a long search to find the text of Senate Bill 1490, enacted in 2006.  It doesn't provide specific requirements, only requires the existing Cemetery and Funeral Bureau to adopt further regulations concerning endowment care. 

In Illinois, the Illinois Cemetery Perpetual Trust Authorization Act (see http://ilga.gov/legislation/ilcs/ilcs3.asp?ActID=2135&ChapterID=61) seems to be the operative law at this time.  T
he recently passed Cemetery Care Act (see http://codes.lp.findlaw.com/ilstatutes/760/100) provides endless definitions and requirements for cemeteries to follow. 

A layman, like this graveyard rabbit,. finds it nearly impossible to discern actual requirements from these legal sites.

There may be problems with perpetual care requirements for some cemeteries.  The section on "Maintenance Funds: on the USLegal.com website (http://cemeteries.uslegal.com/cemetery-maintenance/maintenance-funds/) notes:

"
The flow of funds becomes an obvious problem when the cemetery is full and no additional plots can be sold. At that point the cemetery must rely only on investment returns to cover maintenance costs. But this under-funding is a problem for other stakeholders at other times, too. Plot owners and relatives need to be assured that perpetual maintenance funds do not run out of money and that cemetery owners will not be coming back to the descendants asking for funds for upkeep."

This rabbit is not sure that "perpetual care" really means "forever" in reality!

Thursday, January 5, 2012

A Rabbit's Review 1/5/2012


A Rabbit's Review
By LisaMary Wichowski

Digging Up the Dead: A History of Notable American Reburials
Michael Kammen
Hardcover: 272 pages
University Of Chicago Press (May 1, 2010)
ISBN-13: 978-0226423296

Rest in Peace?  Apparently not for many of the dearly departed.  Michael Kammen’s book Digging up the Dead demonstrates just how fungible the “final” resting places can be. Although reburial is not exclusively an American phenomenon, indeed the relics of medieval Christians are a direct forerunner of the practice, Kammen focuses on the politics and commodification of particular dead individuals as a way illustrating the commercialization of death itself.
Kammen surveys how local pride, fluidity of remembrance and instability of reputation interact in the competition over remains such as for Abraham Lincoln, Jefferson Davis and Sitting Bull.   Each of these reburials shows that what remains has become a mere object where the wishes of the former individual, preferences of the family, and needs of the community are weighed and balanced, and in some cases only to be weighed, balanced again for a further move.
Digging Up The Dead relates how Edgar Allan Poe, ironically enough, was subjected to repeated disruption.  From his death in 1849 he lay unmarked in his wife’s family’s plot until 1873 when a fellow poet, dismayed by the untended grave, published an essay about it that received international attention.  A monument was funded and readied for the back of the churchyard where Poe lay.  The monument was so large, however, that a foundation needed to be built in a way that required Poe’s bones be moved.  Initially the remains were re-interred in the grave of his mother in law, which would also be located under the new memorial.  During the planning stages for the re-interment, the committee in charge decided that the monument should be located in a more accessible spot in the graveyard.  This required approval from the descendants of the original owners of the grave.  In 1875 the monument, Poe’s remains and those of his mother-in-law were all moved with much pageantry to a new, more prominent resting place nearer the front of the same graveyard.  This was not the end of the disruptions of Poe’s eternal rest, however.  In 1883 Poe’s wife’s remains were apparently rescued from a cemetery that was being razed, so in 1885 Poe’s tomb was once again opened to receive the remains of his much beloved spouse.  
Poe’s journey helps to illustrate just how the garden cemetery movement was dependent on celebrity for tourism and for marketing purposes.  The founders of Laurel Hill in Philadelphia expressed “eagerness” to have “historically important” people buried there.  More recently, the heirs and executors of the will of artist Mark Rothko battled over a reburial plan.  Many in the community of the original burial were quite unhappy to see him leave, because as one member of the local cemetery association said, "He's our only notable person."
Unfortunately, it is not only commercial enterprises that are interested in using the famous dead to drive tourism.  Entire communities may battle with families for the right to possess and exploit remains in such cases as Jesse James or Daniel Boone.  Kammen’s analysis of this phenomenon heightens our understanding of how public access to bodies can become highly charged, whatever the original motivation for reburial.  The bodies themselves become mere hostages in the battle over who gets responsibility for the final crafting of the deceased’s legacy.
            That responsibility may be what interests many taphophiles.  There are current debates concerning cemeteries’ appearances, whether it is the painted tomb controversy in Louisiana, the aesthetics of lawn cemeteries, or the level and type decorations for holidays on individual plots.  This well researched, engaging book may not answer all of those questions,  but, it will contribute to the discussions of who owns the dead, their memories and their mythos in a fruitful and interesting way.