Saturday, November 27, 2010

Tech T.I.P. 11/25/2010

Discover Digital Libraries

Denise Barrett Olson

The last couple of years has brought a growing buzz of news about e-books and readers like the Kindle, Nook and iPad. Actually, electronic books (e-books) have been around for quite some time. Groups like the Project Gutenberg folks have been digitizing public domain books for years. And, a growing number of archives are discovering the benefits of digitizing their collections. Not only does this provide a way to make these delicate items available for public access, but it's also a cost-effective disaster management plan.

The e-reading craze has been a boon to researchers as many more public domain books are being digitized to add to the pool of books available on these devices. I'm especially delighted to see more and more local and military histories appear along with memoirs, journals and diaries. While Benjamin Taylor's Pictures of Life in Camp and Field will never be a best seller, to someone researching the Civil War battles at Lookout Mountain and Missionary Ridge, it could be a treasure-trove of information.

Cemetery researchers also benefit as a growing number of books about cemeteries are also showing up in these libraries. For example, at the Internet Archive you'll find books from the American Battle Monuments Commission for each of the American cemeteries in Europe. These books contain photos, maps, history of the cemetery and the battles that populated it.

Why are these digital resources important? They give us a snapshot of the area or cemetery at the time the book was published. In my case, a cemetery inventory from 1892-93 includes descriptions of wooden grave markers that no longer exist. I found a copy of that inventory spread across several issues of the New England Historical and Genealogical Register.

Where can you find these books? A good place to start is the Internet Archive. Their collection covers texts, images, video and audio - and don't forget the Web's Wayback Machine. In the Texts section, searches for "cemetery", "graveyard", "tombstone" and "epitaph" turn up dozens of titles. Books can be viewed in your web browser or downloaded in any number of formats. By the way . . . the Allen County Public Library Genealogy Center is one of Internet Archive's digitizing sponsors and you can keep up with their contributions by visiting their page at the site.

Most of us are already familiar with Google Books as a research resource. Here you'll find both public domain and copyrighted publications. Google also offers both in-the-browser viewing and download options. Project Gutenberg is the grandfather of public domain libraries and another great resource. They have recently updated their interface making it even more user-friendly. The online reader is still only plain text but they are offering a growing number of download options.

If you are lucky enough to have an e-reader (or are expecting one from Santa), you might find FeedBooks and ManyBooks.net handy. There is no web-based viewer - only downloads - but my experience has been that these books have less formatting and OCR errors than other sources. Both offer RSS feeds to keep up with new titles added to the library.

Take some time and browse "the stacks" of these digital libraries to see what gems you can find. I think you'll be pleasantly surprised. Good hunting!

Labels:

Thursday, November 18, 2010

The History Hare - 11/18/2010







“Mary Todd Lincoln's Bloody Cloak”

by footnoteMaven

"'Biohistory'—the combination of biological testing and history—is one of the most exciting new fields of scientific inquiry."
~ Lori Andrews ~


On the evening of April 14, 1865, Abraham and Mary Todd Lincoln attended a performance of "Our American Cousin" at Ford's Theatre in Washington, D.C. Here, as we are all aware, President Lincoln was shot in the back of the head by assassin John Wilkes Booth.

Two physician's were attending the performance and rushed to the president's box where they tried desperately to save President Lincoln's life. One of those physicians, Dr. Charles S. Taft, cut away a small patch of Lincoln's hair in an attempt to treat the bullet wound.

On April 15, 1865, President Lincoln died without having regained consciousness. Dr. Taft held on to the patch of hair throughout the night. After Lincoln passed away, Taft tried to return the lock of the dead President's hair to his widow. She refused and asked the doctor to keep it as a gift for his efforts in trying to save the president's life. Dr. Taft kept those strands of hair and they became a family heirloom handed down to many subsequent generations. [1]

One of the most powerful artifacts related to this terrible event is the cloak allegedly worn by Mrs. Lincoln on the night of the assassination. Mary purportedly gave the cloak to former slave and personal confidante, Elizabeth Keckley.

"Mrs. Lincoln gave away everything intimately connected with the President, as she said that she could not bear to be reminded of the past. The articles were given to those who were regarded as the warmest of Mr. Lincoln's admirers. All of the presents passed through my hands. The dress that Mrs. Lincoln wore on the night of the assassination was given to Mrs. Slade, the wife of an old and faithful messenger. The cloak, stained with the President's blood, was given to me, as also was the bonnet worn on the same memorable night. Afterwards I received the comb and brush that Mr. Lincoln used during his residence at the White House." [2]

The cloak is owned by the Chicago Historical Society. In 2007, the family of a person suffering from Marfan Syndrome approached the Society asking that DNA testing be done on the cloak. It has been speculated by doctors for quite some time that Lincoln suffered from Marfan and the family making the request hoped a definitive result would increase interest and funding into the disease. [3]

Testing of the cloak may not be as straight forward as you might think. It is possible Lincoln's blood is not the only blood on the cloak. Henry Rathbone, a guest in the Lincolns' box, was slashed by the knife of assassin John Wilkes Booth's. Rathbone bled profusely and some of his blood may be mixed with that of the President on Mrs. Lincoln's cloak. How many hands has the cloak passed through from Mrs. Lincoln to the Historical Society? The chain of evidence of historical artifacts such as the cloak may be problematic, particularly where they have been kept and handled by amaturers.

So, while the cloak belongs to the Historical Society, does the DNA on the cloak? Do the results of DNA testing belong to the Society, the public, Lincoln ancestors, or to history?

Many Illinois and North Carolina residents are anxious to match their DNA to this most beloved U.S. President. But what if something shows up in Lincoln's DNA that would cast aspersions on Lincoln or his presidency? Is everything fair game, even if it changes how we view history?

What are the rights of the departed historical figures and their living relatives? Whose permission will be required if any to allow testing? Will the results of the testing be made public? How might medical information impact living relatives?

I, for one, don't have the answers; I don't even know all the questions. The law and biohistory are not presently in the same moment. As of January 2008, the National Conference of State Legislatures indicates that 17 states require informed consent for a third party either to perform or require a genetic test or to obtain genetic information. Twenty-seven states require consent to disclose genetic information. Alaska, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, and Louisiana explicitly define genetic information as personal property. Alaska also extends personal property rights to DNA samples. In 2001 Oregon repealed its property right to DNA samples and genetic information. Four states mandate individual access to personal genetic information, and 19 states have established specific penalties - civil, criminal or both - for violating genetic privacy laws. With respect to privacy, Washington is the only state that explicitly treats genetic information the same as other health information by including genetic information in the definition of health care information under the state health privacy law.

Lori Andrews, an attorney who was asked by the Chicago Historical Society to help create guidelines for genetic research, is the author of more than 100 articles on genetics, alternative modes of reproduction, and biotechnology. Her book, Future Perfect: Confronting Decisions About Genetics (New York: Columbia University Press, 2001), outlines the policy models that should be considered in an age of increasing knowledge of the human genome. Progress is being made and hopefully we will soon have the answers we seek, provided of course we ask the correct questions.

I firmly believe that no harm can ever come from presenting the truth with regard to history. History doesn't change, only the facts and our perception of those facts change. Jeremy Boggs of the Center for History and New Media wrote, ". . . History is never finished, and no one ever really writes the "final word” or “final version” of history. We’re always adding to our historical knowledge, always improving and adding to our various historical narratives. History, then, is perpetual beta." I could not agree more. History is perpetual beta.

In 1999, the Chicago Historical Society and the University of Illinois at Chicago hosted a conference of historians, forensic scientists, and preservationists to consider authentication of Mary Todd Lincoln's cloak. [4] They recommended that DNA testing of the cloak not be done at that time. They determined the process would be too destructive to the cloak and there is no Lincoln genetic marker. At this time investigators are conducting an analysis of the material of the cloak. They are also looking for relatives of Nancy Hanks to provide a mitochondrial DNA reference sample.

The Chicago Historical Society has created a comprehensive website titled Wet With Blood: The Investigation of Mary Todd Lincoln's Cloak that tells the story of the artifacts and their investigation. The site was developed by the Historical Society and Northwestern University, assisted by associations ranging from the Illinois State Police Forensic Sciences Command to the Chicago Institute of Music Chorale. Although not providing answers, it is very interesting reading.

I would also recommend the article Secrets From The Grave, written by Lori Andrews for Parade Magazine. It was the inspiration for this blog article and is an excellent discussion of where we are and where we are going.

For a light-hearted look at DNA testing read Marie Antoinette, Is That You?, by Michelle Slatalla for the New York Times. I recognized her husband, I think I live with his clone.

______________________
[1] Several of them were even set into a ring and given as a gift to President Theodore Roosevelt. Lathrop-Vitu, Lesley. "Lincoln's Locks: The Relics of a Secular Saint". Illinois Humanities Council. (http://www.prairie.org/index.cfm/fuseaction/
dir_resources.detours_page/page_id/c45e3670-53c8-4ade-8a3b-b706d04c6609/
object_id/42c251b0-4088-4654-a1a9-176056c3f082/
LincolnsLocksTheRelicsofaSecularSaint.cfm : 20 October 2007)
[2] Keckley, Elizabeth.
Behind the Scenes; Or, Thirty years a Slave, and Four Years in the White House. University of Michigan Web Site (http://moa.umdl.umich.edu/cgi-bin/moa/
sgml/moa-idx?notisid=ABN905 : 20 October 2007).
[3] People with Marfan syndrome tend to have tall and slender bodies with arms and legs disproportionately long compared to the trunk. They also usually have long fingers and toes. The ligaments and joints are typically loose. Because of rib overgrowth, the chest may protrude or be indented. Abnormal curving of the spine, called scoliosis (sko-le-O-sis), lordosis (lor-DO-sis), or kyphosis (ki-FO-sis), can occur.http://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/health/dci/Diseases/mar/mar_whatis.html
[4] Testing for Marfan syndrome is not a part of the Chicago Historical Society's collaborative investigation.

Photograph:

Unknown, photographer. “[Lincoln, Mrs. Abraham.]” Photograph. Washington, D.C.: L.C. Handy Studios, c1860-1865. From Library of Congress: Brady-Handy Collection, 1861-1865. (http://lcweb2.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/
I?fsaall,app,brum,detr,swann,look,gottscho,pan,horyd,genthe,var,cai,cd,
hh,yan,bbcards,lomax,ils,prok,brhc,nclc,matpc,iucpub,tgmi,lamb:20:./temp/
~pp_lmVG::displayType=1:m856sd=cwpbh:m856sf=03451:@@@mdb=fsaall,app,brum,detr,
swann,look,gottscho,pan,horyd,genthe,var,cai,cd,hh,yan,bbcards,lomax,ils,prok,brhc,
nclc,matpc,iucpub,tgmi,lamb : 12 October 2007).

Updated from the 2007 research and article.

Thursday, November 11, 2010

Graveyard Guru 11/11/2010

Tombstones for the Innocent:
A Short Essay on Victorian Children’s Gravemarkers
By Stephanie Lincecum
I have a book on my shelf that I find myself returning to time and again when conducting cemetery and specific tombstone research. It is Cemeteries & Gravemarkers: Voices of American Culture, edited by R. E. Meyer. It is a collection of works by several different authors. When re-reading the first essay for the umpteenth time, Innocents in a Worldly World: Victorian Children’s Gravemarkers by Ellen M. Snyder, it occurred to me that many of us see these types of tombstones quite often. But do we all know their origin?
The Victorian Era is the period of Queen Victoria’s reign from 1837 to 1901 in the United Kingdom. It was marked with peace and prosperity for the British people. Since the empire was so prominent, their attitudes, art and culture spread across the world. After the Civil War the United States could be characterized as a “Victorian America.” From roughly 1875 to 1910 the British cultural influence was reflected, especially in the heavily populated regions of New England and the deep South. This period was marked with a second industrial revolution and the growing upper class copying the high society of the UK in dress, morality, and mannerisms.
A great place to still see this cultural influence today is in the cemetery. In the Victorian Era, gone was the fear of death and the grim reaper. Death was almost embraced. Strong beliefs in the teachings of the Bible -- the belief in eternal life -- is seen all over our American cemeteries. Epitaphs such as “not dead, but sleepeth,” large crosses, asa well as depictions of angels and heaven all trace back to the Victorian Era. And this attitude was not lost on the youngest to be laid to rest. Children’s grave markers of this period are poignant and beautiful works of art.
According to Ellen Snyder, “By the late 1830s, the concept of childhood innocence was beginning to be highly valued. Perceived as untamed blossoms, children were seen as pure, unblemished, and lacking in artifice. They were closely associated with the home, which stood in marked contrast to the world outside…As innocent beings, small babes were untouched by outside forces; they were not part of ‘the world.’ And if they died, they were depicted in the cemetery in a way that would have been denied to them had they reached adulthood. Children’s markers -- specifically, three-dimensional, sculptural depictions of children with domestic artifacts -- are one of the most elaborate material manifestations of a standard urban, middle-class, Protestant, Victorian vocabulary.”
This concept of the purity and innocence of children was bolstered by Christian ideals. Reverend John Morison wrote in an 1842 sermon, “Their angel innocence shall remain unsullied by a breath from this sinful world.” And Theodore Cuyler wrote in an 1867 Cedar Christian newspaper column, “Parents! Spare your tears for those whom you have laid down to sleep in their narrow earth-beds, with the now withered rose-bud on their breasts. They are safe; Christ has them in his sinless school, where lessons of celestial wisdom are learned by eyes that never weep.” As Ellen Snyder put it, “Children who died had the surest guarantees of sinless afterlives.”

The most common sculpture of a child found in the cemetery is one of a sleeping babe, a recurring Victorian theme. A vision of a child safely tucked away in bed is a metaphor for a good, innocent, Godly child. A lamb is another familiar symbol of innocence in the Victorian cemetery. Ellen Snyder says the lamb “expresses the particularly nineteenth-century vision of the child as close to nature. Nature…had become associated with peace and virtue in the face of an urbanizing nation.”
Another tombstone sculpture sometimes tied to children connects to the Victorian usage of empty furniture to symbolize a deceased loved one. An example would be a small unfilled bed, crib, or chair. A pair of infant shoes may also be seen as well, clearly representing a child now gone. Other props sculpted may include toys such as rattles, teddy bears, or a rocking horse.
Ultimately, as Ellen Snyder states, “children in the cemetery remain forever young, more notable for their deaths than their short lives.”

Labels:

Thursday, November 4, 2010

Digging for Answers 11/4/2010

Welcome to the Digging for Answers column on the Graveyard Rabbit Online Journal.


This column will depend on your submission of questions about cemeteries, gravestones, burial practices, and other topics that concern a Graveyard Rabbit (other than where his next carrot is coming from!). So please send some questions to the editor, who will pass them along and keep the columnist hopping.

Question:

Scott asks: Why are bodies buried facing certain directions (east-west, north-south, etc.), or in certain attitudes (head up, head down, etc.)?

Answer:

We will discuss this as related to current burial practices in Western countries, and not related to practices before the 20th century. If someone wonders about earlier burial practices, we can discuss this in another column.

The burial orientation seems to be related to the religious beliefs of the deceased person and his/her family. For instance:

Christian burials are made in an extended position, lying flat with arms and legs straight, or with the arms folded on the chest, and with the eyes and mouth closed. The body may be laid lying on the back (supine) or on the front (prone). Traditionally, Christian burials were made with the body, in or out of a wooden, metal or concrete coffin, supine and with the head to the western end of the grave and the feet to the east. The tradition is that, at the coming of Christ, presumably in Israel, the faithful will be resurrected facing east. However, sometimes ordained Christian clergy are buried with the heads to the east and feet to the west, so as to be able to minister to their flock at the Resurrection.

In Jewish burials, the body lies flat, covered by a simple shroud, and is placed in a wooden coffin with no metal parts. I didn't see any traditions concerning coffin orientation in the article Jewish Funeral Customs: Saying Goodbye to a Loved One.

In Islamic burials, the body is placed in a shroud on its right side, without a coffin, and is placed in the ground with the head pointed toward, and the face turned toward, Mecca, the holiest place in Islam. There is more information in Islamic Funeral Rites.

Most modern Buddhists are cremated. However, a notable exception to this is the practice of sky burial by Tibetan Buddhists, in which a human corpse is cut in specific locations and placed on a mountaintop, exposing it to the elements and animals.

It was difficult to find current burial practices for Native-Americans. The Cherokee Blackfeet Cultural Circle website describes burial customs, including washing the body, wrapping it in a white cloth or sheet, putting it into a coffin, and burying it in the ground before the next sundown.

Thank you for the question, Scott.
 
Readers - please submit questions to the Online Graveyard Rabbit Journal editor, and she will pass them along for me to dig into and answer.

Labels: