Thursday, October 28, 2010

A Rabbit's Review 10/28/2010

Pioneer Cemeteries Sculpture Gardens of the Old West, By Annette Stott
2008
University of Nebraska Press 404 pp.$36.95
978-0-8032-1608-2

Review by LisaMary Wichowski

I’ve been known to complain about the interest in American burial themes being far too centered on New England, or even the East Coast more generally. I {may} have to stop now. Annette Stott’s Pioneer Cemeteries; Sculpture Gardens of the Old West goes a long way to filling that gap. This is a book about cemeteries, but more still, it’s a book about the Rocky Mountains, as a cradle of women’s entrepreneurship, as a remote, as a place where the self-made imposed their rule.

Stott is an art historian by training and brings this toolkit to use in understanding frontier cemeteries as sculpture gardens and often the only public art available in the Western towns. She focuses on community cemeteries in Colorado, Utah, Wyoming, Idaho and Montana as a distinct region, as the Rocky Mountain west has a unique culture and has been inflected by Spanish Catholic, Native American, Asian, LDS and other American Pioneer groups.

Western frontier towns evolved differently than towns and counties back East. The mixing of the traditions created a distinctive regional culture where a village green was no longer the primary community space but rather where burial ground functioned as ritual, political and artistic space. The burial places reflect the growth of mining camp to mercantile center in their shift from “boot hills” to more polished “fair mounts.”

Impeccably researched, her work in the business and newspaper archives brings to life what was unique about life reflected in commemoration in the region. She uses to good effect newspaper accounts, business archives and legal documents to follow the roles of women as community members and as art objects. The discussion of Mary DeVille Rauh and the M. Rauh Marble Works does both. The business and its artisans produced works which trace the artistic development of memorials from deeply masculine scaled down miner’s cabins to idealized female figures as mourning increasingly became the domain of women. The story of Mary DeVille Rauh, on the other hand, illustrates exactly how difficult it is to parse the role of women in a community. Rauh herself is apparently a self-made woman, arriving in Denver in 1870. By 1877 she had married, had her husband declared violently insane and remarried. The assets she gained in marriage helped build M. Rauh and for twenty years she was signatory of documents of the business that carried her name. What role was played by this woman in growing a business that flourished among the middle and upper classes of Denver? It’s a shame we can never know.

Stott is willing to explore the shifts in manner of commemoration as well as the growth of any given cemetery are reflective of a community’s development. She also skillfully illustrates how memorializations, or the lack of them, can play conflicting roles between the public and the private. In essence she is discovering what audience a memorial is primarily playing to, and how that audience may change over time.

All of the black and white images, plus well over 100 color images used to illustrate key concepts are available online (www.annettestott.com) helping to make this resource a valuable teaching tool for courses on visual or material culture. The images on the website have certainly given me a list of new cemeteries to visit and new communities to explore.

As thorough as Professor Stotts’s book is, it cannot be comprehensive. She acknowledges leaving out cemeteries related to institutional settings and those of communities not intended for permanent settlement. That said, it sets a very high standard to those continuing to work in the West. Opportunities for similar studies of the Pacific Northwest and Canadian Rockies still exist and I can’t wait to read them.

Labels:

Friday, September 3, 2010

A Rabbit's Review 9/3/2010

A Rabbit's Review
by LisaMary Wichowski

Note: A Rabbits Review column replaces The Educated Rabbit column with Sheri's retirement. Do you have a suggested book or website for Mary to review? If so, send an email to your Editor.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

The American Resting Place: Four Hundred Years of History Through Our Cemeteries and Burial Grounds

By Marilyn Yalom,
Photographs by Reid S. Yalom
Houghton Mifflin, 336 pp., $30

Books about death by their very nature tend to come from deep within an author, and Marilyn Yalom's The American Resting Place is no exception. As for many of us, it is the lives represented in the burial places she visits, the lives of the dead, that draw her in. However, her interest is not merely personal: Yalom succeeds in representing American history and geographic expansion, conveyed through a sense of place, time and group identity.

In a three year mother-son trip from New England through the South and onward to Hawaii Marilyn and Reid Yalom leave no doubt that burial grounds can be a significant tool in understanding sociological identity and change.

Marilyn Yalom, a senior Scholar at Stanford’s Institute for Research on Women and Gender and the author of three prior books that link cultural ideas to historical processes (A History of the Breast (1998); A History of the Wife (2002); Birth of the Chess Queen (2004)), is quite practiced in well-done, readable histories. Reid Yalom is a San Francisco based fine art photographer whose first book of photographs, Colonial Noir: Photographs From Mexico, was published by Stanford University Press in the spring of 2004 and whose photographs have been exhibited at galleries in San Francisco and New York. As in Let us Now Praise Famous Men the “parallel narrative” of photographs does not merely support the story, they are truly an integral part of the work, a tale of images hand in hand with the portfolio of written impressions.

The largest portion of the book is a selection of individual cemeteries that are both examples of the evolution of the social context and at the same time artistic expression of death. These sometimes iconic, sometimes closely held, burial places takes us through colonial practices, grave labeling, community identity and group cohesion in the graveyard and the process of the removal of death from American life. Later chapters reveal regional differences as well as the development of the art and culture of cemeteries, with a final chapter focusing on the patterns of change in how we build and experience cemeteries. This is quite a bit of material for one book; there are discussions of First Peoples burial practices; those of the Eastern Seaboard colonists’; Spanish Missions in both Texas and California, Nineteenth century urban cemeteries; Catholic grounds in Chicago, St Louis and New Orleans. There is even a chapter on military cemeteries.

Despite this breadth, there are enough details that weave her argument together. African-Americans are not consigned to details about burials but acknowledged as agents in their own rights, such as in the stonecutting shops of Newport. The New York congregation of Shearith Israel’s cemetery (1682-1831) is used to show how much real estate can matter. At its height the burial ground covered all of Chatham Square. The city of New York ran streets through the cemetery in the early 19th century, and at midcentury extended the Bowery, moving over 200 graves.

The writing is spare, yet in its own way creates vivid mental images of the places visited better than anything more florid would. In her discussion of the changing ethnic makeup of Chicago’s Mt Olive she tells us of “Crosses and Madonnas, photos of the deceased, and sentimental epitaphs enliven the mournful grounds. We stood silently before the tombstone… her epitaph says it all:

“WE LOVE
YOU
SADGIRL
2001”

This clarity of prose. is well echoed by Reid Yalom’s photographs. His touch, as in his images of the mausoleum at Hollywood Forever, can be almost abstract, while the image of the Charles Balmer stone in Bellefontaine of St Louis proves surprisingly intimate. And different from these in turn is the shot of the memorial to Dred Scott, journalistic and yet historic.

Like many cemeteries I have visited, The American Resting Place is easy to wander through, but well worth the care of a slow, attentive visit.

---

LisaMary Wichowski
Portland, OR
Taphopolis.com

LisaMary is finishing her MA in Labor History at UIChicago. She plans on completing her PhD in American Studies with a dissertation on ethnicity and death rituals, that is, tracing patterns of assimilation through how we honor our departed. Her interest in cemeteries is part of her heart and mind. LM's heart loves them for the tales they tell us about individuals, her mind for the stories they share about our community and culture.

Labels: